Tuesday, 3 May 2016

(5/2) How to ensure you understand an article

When we complete a Language Analysis, we must ensure that we understand what the article is asking us. Thus we must ask and be able to answer the following question.


  • Why has this person decided to write the article?
  • What topic is he addressing in the article?
  • What outcome is he attempting to achieve through the article?
  • What reasons is he providing to support his outcome?
  • What attitude is the author depicting through the article?

Examples 


  • Why has this person decided to write the article?

  • What topic is he addressing in the article?

  • What outcome is he attempting to achieve through the article?

  • What reasons is he providing to support his outcome?

  • What attitude is the author depicting through the article?

(4/2 ) An Audience NOT an Audience By Any Other Name


When we write pieces of writing we often address it at a certain 'type' of person and section of society. We call this the intended reader. It is important that we

(3/2) PLTs: Identification and Analysis



LEARNING INTENTION: To learn what PLT’s are, how to analyse them and be able to construct a full sentence that outlines that analysis.

Check your understanding:

•I can construct a sentence that reflects my analysis of the PLTs of a particularly article

•I understand what a PLT is

•I understand how PLTs are intended to impact on a reader

•I can explain why it is important to target specific readerships in my analysis

•I can analyse how PLT’s are used to persuade the reader

•I can communicate the analysis of PLT’s in full sentences


Learning Activity: Complete the crossword by matching the descriptions to the persuasive language techniques


Persuasive Language Techniques

}Pun: Clever work play

}Facts and statistics: Including evidence from credible research.

}Formal Tone: using correct grammar and language rather than casual or colloquial forms.

}Expert Opinion: Quoting from experts relevant to the topic

}Examples: Including clear examples of your point from real life.

}Rebuttal: Identifying a potential opposing argument and pointing out its flaws or weaknesses.

}Rule of three: Including a series of three ideas to create a mnemonic.

}Anecdotes: adding a personal story.

}Attacks and praise: Providing negative comments about an opponent.

}Rhetorical Question: Asking questions that don’t require an answer but engage the reader.

}Bias: Presenting a one sided argument

}Imagery: using words to create an image in the readers head

}Alliteration: Words play that involves the same letter or sound of words in a row

}Hyperbole: Making exaggerated claims.

}Generalization: making general comments and representations
Persuasive Language

}Descriptive language: language that creates a clear image in the readers mind

}Figurative language: Using metaphors and similes.

}Emotive language: Emotionally charged words

}Inclusive language: including the audience by using personal pronouns

}Colloquial language: Using language that places the author on the same level as an every day person.

}Jargon: Using subject specific language 


Appeals 

}Appeal to common sense: appealing to the readers common sense

}Logic: making an argument seem logical

}Appeal to nationalism: Making an appeal to the readers sense of national identity

}Appeal to hip-pocket: Appealing to the authors desire to ensure money is spent wisely.

}Appeal to family: Appealing to the readers desire to protect the family unit.

Write in your book any persuasive language techniques that you are unsure of. This list should assist you when it comes to writing the SAC and CAT.


Learning Activity: Read the article titled 'Choosing is hard, but it’s still a lifestyle choice'by Amanda Vanstone. You need to identify ITACT, 3 supporting arguments and at least 9 PLTs and PL employed by the author.

How to analyse PLTs

When analysing persuasive language techniques you need to focus on three skills.

1. Identify and describe the technique
2. Quote how it has been used
3. Describe the effect on the reader 

1 and 2. Nguyen uses a anecdote when she describes herself 'as the daughter' of asylum seekers.
3. By describing the 'state of horror' she 'fled' from she demonstrates she has an understanding of the issue. This could position families to have a greater respect of her opinion because she appears to speak for all asylum seekers.


Link to article http://mrmunners.blogspot.com.au/2015/04/choosing-is-hard-but-itsstill-lifestyle.html

Reflection: Score yourself out of ten on your understanding of todays lesson.

  • Could you find the crossword words?
  • Could you identify ITACT?
  • Could you identify arguments?
  • Could you identify PLTs?

(2/2) A Tale of Three Arguments: Identification

A Tale of Three Arguments: Identification

Identifying Arguments 101

When making an argument you provide reasons to support your POV. We do this everyday to ensure what we are discussing is backed up by support. In order for our idea to be persuasive it must have support and within a opinion article we call this a supporting argument




LA ESSAY STRUCTURE: The red text shows were the ideas in this blog fit into the LA SA structure.




Introduce understanding of article
Introduction:
Issue/Context, Text Details, Audience, Contention, Tone/Effect of tone
Analysis arguments within article
Body Paragraph 1:
 Analyse how the author uses persuasive language and techniques to argue their first supporting argument. 
1) Identify the first supporting argument.
2) Identify and analyse how PLTs are used to persuade the reader.
3) Identify and analyse how PLTs are used to persuade the reader.

 
Body Paragraph 2:
Analyse how the author uses persuasive language and techniques to argue a second supporting argument.
Body Paragraph 3:
Analyse how the author uses persuasive language and techniques to argue a third supporting argument.
Conclusion:
How is the reader left feeling?
A Start Point:
It is important that we identify the contention. The supporting arguments are constructed to defend the POV the author is trying to make. Without a contention there can be no supporting argument.
Contention: The Australian government and society needs to do more to protect asylum seekers.




Now we have identified the foundation for the supporting arguments to back-up, we have also laid the foundation so we can demonstrate that we understand what the author is arguing.

The question we must ask ourselves is…

}  What supporting arguments does Nguyen employ to argue that Australian society needs to provide a sanctuary to asylum seekers

or

}  What reasons is Giselle Nguyen providing for Australia changing its asylum seeker laws to protect refugees.

or

}  Why does Giselle believe that asylum seekers should be protected by Australia?

In other words…
}  Giselle Nguyen thinks that the Australian government should provide asylum to refugees because…


Now we write our identified arguments in full sentences 

Checklist for the identification of arguments

·         Is it a reason the author is providing for their POV?

·         Reference the author

·         Relate to the issue

·         Be a full sentence


Sample Identification of Arguments.


Original student idea is in italics, revised response demonstrating a full sentence is provided.


A1: The author argues that asylum seekers (They) are being persecuted and subjugated in their home country. 

Original response didn’t refer directly to the author (Nguyen). The response also began with the ambiguous ‘They’ employing the explicit ‘asylum seekers’ links the response directly to the issue. The response also need to address where ‘they’ where being ‘persecuted and subjugated’ thus the revised ‘asylum seekers are being persecuted and subjugated in their home country’ makes an implicit suggestion about why the Australian Government needs to address the issue. This makes a link back into the contention.

A2: Nguyen accuses the Australian Government of being racist with its asylum seeker policy. 

Original response did refer to the author and effectively identified an argument. However the response needed to make a reference to the asylum seeker policy to draw the focus of the argument statement through the issue and the contention.

A3: Nguyen makes the suggestion that asylum seekers have the potential to make valuable contributions to society and thus should be granted asylum.

The original response was poorly expressed, however an argument was identified. Response was re-written to include a reference to the author and the issue.

Contentions


(UNIT1) Week-by-Week Unit Outline: Analysing and Presenting an Argument

Week-by-Week Unit Outline: Analysing and Presenting an Argument

The Following is a week-by-week breakdown for each WEEK the Lessons to be covered are listed. Under each LESSON is a ‘learning intention,’ ‘Check your understanding,’ and the corresponding blog from ‘mrmunners@blogspot.com.au’

WEEK 1

Lesson 1: One Period

Learning Intention:

To understand the purpose of a Language Analysis.

Check Your Understanding:

·          Can I explain the purpose of a LA?

·          Do I understand the idea of a language analysis?

·          Do I understand why we complete LA?

Topics and (related BLOG)


Lesson 2: 1 Period

Learning Intention:

To be able to identify ITACT within an article and effectively communicate this analysis in full sentences.

Check your understanding

·          I understand how to find ITACT in an article

·          I understand what ITACT stands for and what each of the words mean.

·          I can explain how finding ITACT assists with your understanding of the article.

·          I am able to communicate my analysis regarding ITACT in full sentences.

Topics and (related BLOG)



Identifying Issues: (Identifying Issues 101)



Lesson 3: 3 Periods

Romeo and Juliet SAC

WEEK 2

Lesson 4 (2 Periods)

Learning Intention

To learn how to identify an author’s argument within an article

Check Your Understanding

·          I can identify the reasons an author is providing to support his POV

·          I can explain the supporting arguments from an opinion article

·          I can identify and communicate an author’s supporting argument in an opinion article

Topics and (Blog)

How to identify an author’s argument! ((2/2) A Tale of Three Arguments: Identification)

Lesson 5 (3 Periods)

Learning Intention

To learn what PLT’s are, how to analyse them and be able to construct a full sentence that outlines that analysis.

Check Your Understanding

·          I can construct a piece of prose that reflects my analysis of the PLTs of a particularly article

·          I understand what a PLT is

·          I understand how PLTs are intended to impact on a reader

·          I can explain why it is important to target specific readerships in my analysis

·          I can analyse how PLT’s are used to persuade the reader

·          I can communicate the analysis of PLT’s in full sentences

Topics and (Blog)



WEEK 3: (Distribution of LA CAT: Wednesday 6/5

Lesson 6 (2 Periods)

Learning Intention

To be able to analyse persuasive language and how it is intended to persuade a reader of their POV.

Check Your Understanding

•         I understand how PLTs are intended to impact on a reader

•         I can explain why it is important to target specific readerships in my analysis

•         I can analyse how PLT’s are used to persuade the reader

•         I can communicate the analysis of PLT’s in full sentences

Topics and (Blog)


Identifying PLTs and Language: 19/2 A list of PLTs

Learning Activities

PLT TEST #1

Lesson 7a (3 lessons)

Learning Intention

To learn how to put the skills we have learnt in the ‘Arguing and Presenting Arguments’ unit into a well-structured essay.

Check Your Understanding:

•         Understand which skills are required for a language analysis essay.

•         Understand the LA essay structure

•         Be confident in putting the skills learnt into a cohesive essay

•         Be able to write a LA essay

Topics and (Blog)

LA structure- Putting it all together

Putting the skills into an essay- The Cake Recipe

Week 4: (CAT Due: 7/5)

Lesson 7b (2 lessons)

Learning Intention

To be able to improve our analysis of persuasive language, how it is intended to persuade a reader of their POV and be able to communicate it in a coherent form.

Check Your Understanding

LA: Using the Learning Intention above how do you think you could check your understanding. What do you need to have achieved by the end of this lesson

•         Be able to identify a PLT from an article

•         Be able to analyse how PLTs are used to impact a reader

•         Be able to communicate your analyse in full sentences

•         Be able to answer why

Topics and (Blog)

Writing complex responses- Answering the Why?

Making sure your analysis relates to the contention and issue- Avoiding Vague Analysis

Focusing on improving your analysis- Analysis Focusing on Body Paragraphs

How to write a conclusion- Writing a Kick Arse Conclusion

Learning Activities

Analysing Images

Lesson 8 (2 Lessons)

Learning Intention

To begin annotating and analysing the CAT article and improve our understanding of the homosexual marriage issue.

Check Your Understanding

•         Annotate the CAT article

•         Identify ITACT for the CAT article

•         Have an understanding of the homosexual marriage issue.

Topics and (Blog)

Annotating the CAT article

Peer assessment: introductions

Introduction and Analysing the image

Lesson 9 (1 Lesson)

Learning Intention

To begin/continue writing and planning the LA CAT and learn how to analyse images/cartoons

Check Your Understanding

•         To have written an intro and received feedback

•         To have annotated the article

•         To have identified several arguments

•         To have substantially planned the essay

Topics and (Blog)

Peer assessment for INTRO

How to Write a Kick Arse Intro: LA Edition

WEEK 5

Lesson 10 (2 Lessons)

Learning Intention

To reflect explicitly on the CAT and identify how we can improve our LA writing

Check Your Understanding

·          I understand what I need to improve for my CAT

·          I am aware of how I am going to improve

·          I have written an action plan to improve my writing

Topics and (Blog)

CAT Reflection worksheet and action plan

Lesson 11 (2 Lessons)

Learning Intention

Lesson 1: To use the LA CAT reflection to improve our understanding LA writing and to improve individual skills and the quality of our LA writing.

Lesson 2: To practice specific skills, based on the reflections on the CAT in completing 2 of 3 mini tasks.

Check Your Understanding

·          I can identify and describe the contention

·          I can identify, describe and analyse the tone of an article

·          I can accurately identify the issue from an article

·          I can identify how the intended audience is specific based on the contention and issue.

·          I can write an effective conclusion

·          I can effectively structure a body paragraph

Topics and (Blog)

Workshops to improve student understanding



Identifying Issues: (Identifying Issues 101)


How to write a Conclusion:

Lesson 12 (1 Lessons)

Learning Intention

To develop a process of annotation and essay planning for the LA unit

Check Your Understanding

·          I can employ a repetitive process to annotate and plan an LA essay

·          I understand how to follow the flow planning chart

·          I can use the flow planning chart to improve my essay writing

Topics and (Blog)

The LA Planning Flow Chart

Week 6

Lesson 13 (1 Lesson)

Learning Intention

To be able to annotate a LA article and identify arguments, language and techniques in preparation for writing a language analysis essay

Check Your Understanding

•         I can analyse language

•         I can annotate an article in 10 mins

•         I know what to look for when annotating

•         I can annotate and plan a language analysis essay sufficiently in preparation for the SAC and end of semester exam.

Topics and (Blog)

How to Annotate an your article

Learning Activities:

1. Quick Annotate: Andrew Charles article

2. Class Annotate: Devine article

3. Team Essay: Series of articles

Lesson 14 (1 Lesson)

Learning Intention

To mark and provide feedback for a series of sample essays and identify at least 3 techniques to be applied to our own writing

Check Your Understanding

•         I can annotate an article in 5 mins

•         I know what to look for when annotating

•         I can focus on and analyse a specific word

•         I can analyse language in an organised and coherent form (LA Structure)

•         I can complete a language analysis essay to a satisfactory standard

Topics and (Blog)

How to annotate an article

Practice essays

Lesson 15 (1 Lesson)

Learning Intention

To revisit the language analysis structure and consolidate our ability to analyse persuasive devices

Check Your Understanding

Topics and (Blog)

Practice essay writing

Practice Articles on blog

Learning Activities

PLT TEST #2

Lesson 16 (1 Lesson)

Learning Intention

To improve our ability and the complexity of our analysis

Check your understanding:

•         I can focus on and analyse a specific word

•         I know which words to focus on and why they are important

•         I can analyse language

•         I can annotate an article in 5 mins

•         I know what to look for when annotating

•         I can construct complex analysis

Topics and (Blog)

Practice essay writing

Learning Activities

1. Quick Annotate: Sue Davis article

2. PLT TEST #3

3. Community Circle Analysis activity (Building Blocks)

Lesson 17 (1 Lesson)

Learning Intention

To use teacher and peer feedback to practice writing a Language analysis essay in preparation for the SAC/Exam

Check Your Understanding

Students to identify 3 skill areas they feel they could improve upon and phrase them as check your understanding

· I can write a LA essay

Topics and (Blog)

Practice essay writing

Learning Activities

1. Quick Annotate: Gorging the Innocent

2. PLT TEST #1

Week 7 (SAC: Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday)

Lesson 18 (3 Lessons)

Language Analysis SAC: Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday.